About the author

Steven HarmanSteven Harman is a passionate developer who believes that writing great software isn't just a job, its a craft.

ASP.NET MVP

For recent posts and more about me, scroll to the bottom.

Subscribe

  • Subscribe to my feed. via RSS
  • Subscribe via email via email

News

devLINK Technical Conference

Jobs

Badges

  • Subtext Project
  • Support Subtext
  • HiddenNetwork.com Banner

What Makes a Blog Popular?

After reading Jeff's post about advertising on your blog and why it's so deliciously evil I thought I'd look into a few of the ad services he mentioned. Hey, I'll take a few extra bucks if you want to shill your stuff on my blog... and then I'll knock your product anyhow. I'm a huge fan of spite!

But I digress.

I was checking out some of Text Link Ads' free tools and I came across the Blog Juice Calculator. As best I can tell this is nothing more than a tool, and I use that term loosely, to judge the relative popularity of a blog and/or web site.

How did I fare?

I started with this blog's URL, stevenharman.net, and then chose Computer/Technology as the category. Not surprisingly my blog rated near the low end bringing in just 2.4 out of a possible 10 Blog Juice points.

Get Your Blog JuiceFor added fun I thought I'd see how I stacked up against my friend Phil. Not surprisingly Haacked.com came in at a much higher number - 6.9.

And then just for kicks I added Jeff Atwood's CodingHorror.com blog into the mix. This time I was a bit surprised.

As the chart to the left shows, Haacked pulled down a full 1 Blog Juice Point more than Coding Horror. I'm not sure exactly what it is that I find surprising... it's just not what I was expecting.

A theory... maybe

After digging into the Blog Juice statistics I have come to a conclusion... or at least an explanation that I can pass off as plausible.

One blog is very tightly focused and has a large number of loyal and dedicated readers whom subscribe and link to the blog regularly.

The other is still technology focused but in a much broader sense - focusing on the less tangible aspects of computing and programming.

As I see it...

The more focused blog fares better in this type of popularity contest because of its loyal fan base and large number of backlinks. I believe these characteristics are quite common of active, tightly focused communities.

Alexa RatingsHowever, the other blog is more widely read (per the Alexa stats) but its readers are more likely to be one-hitters and therefore less likely to be subscribers and backlinkers (is that even a word?).

What does all of this mean?

Probably not much. But I find it interesting.

What would be even more interesting would be to know how this derived popularity translates into dollars. Specifically dollars earned through the various advertisements run on these two blogs... but that's a hypothetical conversation to be had over a few pints after we all become Open Source Millionaires Billionaires.

What others are saying.

# re: What Makes a Blog Popular?
Gravatar Simone
Jul 06, 2007
Made the same test... mine is 3.2 juice points, but cannot make an alexe graph since I'm not in the top 100.000
# re: What Makes a Blog Popular?
Gravatar Simone
Jul 06, 2007
The problem with haacked being more popular then codinghorror is because its subscribers are less... probably a problem with how text-link-ads get the rss url
# re: What Makes a Blog Popular?
Gravatar Haacked
Jul 06, 2007
But if you look at FeedBurner subscribers, Jeff has an order of magnitude more than I do. That's a better sign of "loyalty".

As for how this translates to dollars, Jeff is going to make way more than I do. Though I'm happy for any advertisers willing to help prove me wrong. ;)
# re: What Makes a Blog Popular?
Gravatar Steve Harman
Jul 06, 2007
@Haacked: Ah yes... you are correct about the large disparity in Feedburner subscribers. And yes, I would agree that those numbers indicate a large and loyal readership for Mr. Coding Horror.

That said, I suppose we're back to what I said in the post

What does all of this mean?

Probably not much.


Just like in grade school, popularity is relative... and finicky.
Comments have been closed on this topic.